newsdog Facebook

Lenovo Legion 5i 15 vs. Dell Gaming G5 15: Which gaming laptop should you buy?

Windows Central 2020-08-18 22:30:03

Legion Rebranded

Deep Customization

The Legion 5i 15 doesn't have the same RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU option as the Dell Gaming G5 15, but otherwise, performance hardware is almost the same. Its battery options are larger, however, and the rear port hub allows for easy cable management.

$1,449 at Lenovo

Pros

  • Strong, cool performance
  • Many display options
  • Plenty of ports in rear hub
  • Comfortable keyboard with deep travel
  • Larger battery options

Cons

  • Fewer configuration options
  • Starts at a higher price
  • Only available up to RTX 2060 GPU

The Dell Gaming G5 15 has smaller battery sizes, and its low-end options don't come with Wi-Fi 6, but otherwise, it has similar or more powerful performance hardware options. There are plenty of models available, and they start at a more affordable price.

From $824 at Dell

Pros

  • Plenty of configuration options
  • Starts at a more affordable price
  • Up to an RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU
  • Many display options
  • Customizable chassis RGB lighting

Cons

  • Smaller battery sizes
  • No rear port hub
  • No Wi-Fi 6 on low-end models

Lenovo Legion 5i 15 vs. Dell Gaming G5 15 tech specs

Lenovo Legion 5i 15 Dell Gaming G5 15
Processor 10th Gen Intel
Core i5-10300H
Core i7-10750H
10th Gen Intel
Core i5-10300H
Core i7-10750H
RAM 8GB, 16GB DDR4-2933MHz 8GB, 16GB DDR4-2933MHz
Graphics NVIDIA GTX 1650
NVIDIA GTX 1650 Ti
NVIDIA GTX 1660 Ti
NVIDIA RTX 2060
NVIDIA GTX 1650 Ti
NVIDIA GTX 1660 Ti
NVIDIA RTX 2060
NVIDIA RTX 2070 Max-Q
Storage Up to 1TB M.2 PCIe SSD
Up to 1TB 2.5-inch SATA SSD
Dual drives available
Up to 1TB M.2 PCIe SSD
Dual drives available
Display 15.6 inches
1920x1080 (FHD)
60Hz, 120Hz, 144Hz, 240Hz
IPS, anti-glare
15.6 inches
1920x1080 (FHD)
60Hz, 144Hz, 240Hz
IPS, WVA, anti-glare
Ports Four USB-A 3.1
USB-C 3.1 (DP 1.2)
HDMI 2.0
Ethernet
3.5mm audio
Two USB-A 2.0
USB-A 3.2
HDMI 2.0
Ethernet
SD card reader
USB-C DP Alt (GTX 1650 Ti)
Thunderbolt 3 (GTX 1660 Ti or better)
Mini DisplayPort (GTX 1660 Ti or better)
Wireless Intel Wi-Fi 6 AX201
Bluetooth 5.0
Wi-Fi 5
Killer Wi-Fi 6 AX1650
Bluetooth 5.1
Keyboard White backlight
Four-zone RGB
White backlight
Four-zone RGB
Security Kensington lock slot
Webcam shutter
Wedge lock slot
Battery 60Wh, 80Wh 51Wh, 68Wh
Dimensions 14.3 x 10.22 x 0.93 - 1.03 inches
(363.06mm x 259.61mm x 23.57 - 26.1mm)
14.4 x 10 x 0.96 inches (0.85 inches for GTX 1650 Ti)
(365.5mm x 254mm x 24.5mm (21.6mm))
Weight From 5.42 pounds (2.46kg) From 5.18 pounds (2.34kg)

Source: Dell

These two gaming laptops have some definite gaming style, though the Legion — which makes our list of the best gaming laptops —is a bit more understated. If you're looking for a laptop that can double as a productivity machine, it's probably the better pick. The Legion has a logo stamped on the lid with iridescent color (and otherwise a Phantom Black color), while the Gaming G5 has an Interstellar Dark finish that makes it look more like a starry sky. It is iridescent and stands out a lot more for anyone who likes to make a statement.

Along the rear edge of the Legion 5i 15 is a hub for ports that makes cable management a breeze. You still get USB-A ports on either side and a 3.5mm audio jack on the right for each connecting, but otherwise, your video, adapter, and accessory ports are out of the way. Dell's Gaming G5 goes with a more standard approach, with ports along either side. If you need Thunderbolt 3 and an SD card reader, you'll definitely want to opt for Dell's laptop with a GTX 1660 Ti graphics card (GPU) or better.

Source: Windows Central

Both laptops have a full keyboard with number pad, and both should provide a comfortable typing experience. If you're less interested in a lot of gaming flair, you can go with a simple white backlight, though both are also available with four-zone RGB lighting for deeper customization. Both employ a sizable Precision touchpad without physical buttons. You'll no doubt want to invest in one of our picks for best PC gaming mice for serious gaming.

One thing Dell does better than the Legion (at least on models with a GTX 1660 Ti GPU or better) is 12-zone customizable RGB lighting on the chassis. You can have your laptop glowing, unlike the Legion model with RGB contained in the keyboard. For some added security, both laptops have a lock slot, while the Legion laptop steps things up with a webcam shutter for its 720p front-facing camera. Wi-Fi 6 is available in both laptops, though the low-end Dell models come with Wi-Fi 5.

Source: Windows Central

No matter how impressive the performance hardware, a good gaming laptop must have a display that can keep up. In terms of the 5i 15 and G5 15, there are a few 1080p options to choose from.

Baseline Legion models have a rather measly 250 nits brightness with 120Hz refresh rate and middling color, and a step-up provides 300 nits brightness with 100% sRGB color but just a 60Hz refresh rate. The option most people should go for is the one with 300 nits brightness, 144Hz refresh rate, 5ms response time, and 100% sRGB color. A top-end option has 500 nits brightness, Dolby Vision, and a 240Hz refresh rate. These are IPS panels.

Since the Legion is available with up to an NVIDIA RTX 2060 GPU, that 240Hz refresh rate might be wasted (depending on the games you enjoy), though the extra brightness would be great for working and playing outdoors.

Source: Dell

Dell offers both WVA and IPS 1080p display options, starting with the former as a baseline option. It has a 60Hz refresh rate and 300 nits brightness. Stepping up, you can get a WVA display with 300 nits brightness and 144Hz refresh rate. Finally, if you'd like to stick with IPS for better viewing angles and color, you can get a 240Hz refresh rate. And thanks to the Gaming G5 15 coming with up to an NVIDIA RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU, you'll be better equipped to push framerates to that extent.

Other GPU options for the G5 15 include an NVIDIA GTX 1650 Ti, 1660 Ti, and RTX 2060. For the Legion, GPU options (other than the aforementioned RTX 2060) include an NVIDIA GTX 1650, GTX 1650 Ti, and GTX 1660 Ti.

Source: Windows Central

To keep everything cool, both laptops have a dual-fan system with ample exhaust and intake vents. Testing the Legion 5i 15, we saw no thermal throttling thanks to Lenovo's Dual Burn setup, which effectively allows both the CPU and GPU to run together without overheating. Fans are relatively loud, but the laptop remains cool under full load.

On the other hand, the Dell Gaming G5 15 seems to have a bit harder time keeping cool. You're still going to see strong performance from the 10th Gen Intel chips and up to an RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU, but it's not likely going to run as efficiently.

Source: Dell

Both laptops have dual RAM slots that can be upgraded, and the G5 15 has dual M.2 SSD slots that can also be upgraded. If you're more partial to a 2.5-inch SATA SSD, the Legion has room for an upgrade besides its stock M.2 PCIe SSD. And, if you'd rather have dual M.2 SSDs, there's also room; you just have to choose between M.2 or 2.5-inch SATA.

As for battery life, the Legion 5i 15 has a larger 60Wh and 80Wh options compared to Dell's 51Wh and 68Wh batteries. No matter what, neither laptop is going to wow you with battery life. Expect somewhere between one and two hours from a charge while gaming, dipping even lower if the game is particularly hard on the hardware.

The Legion 5i 15 doesn't have Thunderbolt 3, an SD card reader, or as good of GPU options, but it does have a rear port hub, webcam shutter, and impressive cooling that results in no thermal throttling. If you like a less flashy design and strong mid-range performance, it should please.

Legion Rebranded

Cool mid-range performance

Choose from myriad configuration options starting at a competitive price and enjoy mid-range gaming performance without throttling.

Dell's Gaming G5 15 brings extra features, flashy design

With Thunderbolt 3, an SD card reader, customizable RGB chassis lighting, and a far more flashy exterior, the Dell Gaming G5 15 is undeniably attractive. It might not run as cool as the Legion 5i 15, but it does come with up to an RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU for more power. Deep customization and a cheaper starting price means you should find it easier to get precisely what you want.

Deep Customization

Up to an RTX 2070 Max-Q GPU

The Dell Gaming G5 15 brings more hardware options and features to a more stylized gaming laptop.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.